Ok, Guess which ring is going back to the casting company on Monday?

I was so excited to finally get the rings I sent out to be cast, and this is what I got in return. One perfect ring, and one totally distorted mess! I only ordered two castings, so I'm pretty shocked that they decided to send me one that was completely unacceptable. How would I sell this to someone? "Looks better after a few shots of vodka."